4 June 2019

Time for Proxy Advisors

GILES RAFFERTY, Corporate Communications and Media Advisor

AGM season may seem a long way off for many ASX listed companies but June and July are prime time for engaging with proxy advisors in advance of the peak months of proxy season, between August and October.

Proxy advisors play a vital role in helping inform investment managers and asset owners on the resolutions relating to the companies in which they are invested and offering an opinion on how to vote.

Arranging a meeting with a proxy advisor firm can allow senior executives the chance to:

  • discuss how their governance practices are evolving
  • highlight unique issues that may impact on their governance or remuneration practices
  • gain a better understanding of how the proxy advisor firm views the governance requirements for listed companies.

“Often we need to agree to disagree.”
Simon Connal Founder, Ownership matters

We asked the four proxy adviser firms operating in Australia – ISS Australia, CGI Glass Lewis, Ownership Matter and the Australian Council of Superannuation Investors (ACSI) – for their thoughts on the kind of mistakes companies make when engaging with proxy advisors and how they could improve engagement.

What to do and what not to do

Both ACSI and ISS Australia highlighted the importance of not only engaging with proxy advisors but also directly with investors. Vas Kolesnikoff, Head of Australia & New Zealand Research at ISS, noted the 4thEdition of the ASX Corporate Governance Principles and Recommendations requires companies to have an appropriate stakeholder engagement function. “A lot of them just say, “Oh we’ll just pick the top 10 investors and will talk to them”, but, you know, what about the rest of them?” he said.

Louise Davidson, CEO at ACSI suggested companies that receive (activist) shareholder resolutions should proactively engage with those filing the resolutions, as well as their shareholders, rather than ignoring them. “We have seen this happen on occasions in the past”, she commented, adding that “those that do engage are more likely to make in-roads into managing the issues, which may mean there is no need for investors to support the resolutions.”

“On remuneration issues, the implementation of new policies is only clear once the director’s report has been released.”
Daniel  Smith Managing Director, CGI Glass Lewis

Ownership Matters and CGI Glass Lewis said a mistake some companies make is to assume that engaging with a proxy advisor firm will result in that firm agreeing with the company or giving it a ‘clean bill of health’. No matter how positive a meeting between a company and a proxy advisor firm, it will be the governance disclosures and policies revealed in the company’s annual report and market announcements that underpin a proxy advisor’s view of a company.

Where is the heat?

We also asked each of the proxy advisor firms if there were areas of corporate governance where they felt Australian companies should raise their game. All four agreed that companies needed to do more on remuneration, with greater disclosure around executive, performance related, pay targets   and, in particular, short-term incentives.

ISS Australia, CGI Glass Lewis and ACSI also specifically called out ESG reporting and, in particular, action on climate change as important areas for Australian companies to focus on.  Daniel Smith, General Manager at CGI Glass Lewis, has the view ESG reporting needs to sit within the continuum of risk reporting and disclosure so that the company is “explaining how the board oversees material risks, including environmental and social risks”. CGI Glass Lewis also identified ‘explaining corporate strategy’ as an area where Australian companies could raise their game.

“Disclosure of the risks posed by climate change is a major area of focus for investors, as well as regulators including APRA and ASIC.”
Louise Davidson CEO, ACSI

Simon Connal, a founder of Ownership Matters, took the view Australian companies could do more around “moving-on poorly performing directors” and felt that “APRA’s report on CBA tends to validate this issue”. Ownership Matters also highlighted there is more to be done to hold Boards and management accountable for poor capital management, both M&A and capital allocation.

ACSI included Board gender diversity as a priority area where it would like to see continued progress. “We will continue to recommend our members vote against directors on all-male Boards. We are extending this policy to ASX200 companies with one woman director and the ASX300 this year.” Louise Davison said.

Where to begin?

All four proxy advisory firms are happy to meet with companies, but it is worth noting not every advisory firm covers every company. In reality proxy advisors write reports on the companies that their clients, investment managers and asset owners, ask them to. The good news is proxy firms are happy to say whether they do or don’t report on a company, which is a good place to start any engagement with them.

They also, each have a lot of information on their firms’ policies and guidelines available through their websites.

“I would urge companies to look at our policies to understand why we say what we say.”
Vas KolesnikoffHead of Australia & New Zealand Research, ISS

It is worth reviewing the on line material provided by proxy advisor firms prior to seeking a meeting. It is possible interrogating a proxy advisor’s website will give a company a good understanding of how and why that advisor has formed a certain view, which may make a face to face meeting redundant.

One thing all the proxy advisory firms appear to agree on is that listed companies should focus on building effective IR functions that support and maintain constant, appropriate and effective communication with their shareholders as a priority.

3 September 2018

Deal Flow – Retail Investors Have a Point of View

Victoria Geddes, Executive Director Post results reporting season is a time when investment banks start engaging their clients, in advance of the year’s end, to get mergers, spin-offs and takeovers off and running. Witness the recent TPG and Vodafone merger as well as the Coles spin-off from Wesfarmers. The merits of engaging in Proxy Solicitation […]

Read More
29 June 2018

ASIC Review of Proxy Adviser Engagement Practices

Victoria Geddes, Executive Director Following FIRST Adviser’s ‘Time to talk to Proxy Advisers’ post last month, ASIC has published its review of proxy adviser engagement practices. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission acted after business organisations complained some proxy firms are unwilling to engage, correct inaccuracies or give time for companies to clarify errors. ASIC’s […]

Read More
7 December 2017

FIRST Advisers ranked the Number 1 Australian Proxy Solicitation firm

The FIRST Advisers’ Proxy Solicitation practice has taken a prime position in the 2017 Intermediary Awards, as the top ranked Australian Proxy firm and the 6th ranked globally. FIRST Advisers is the only Australian specialist in Activist campaigns to feature in the top 10 rankings, which are dominated by US and European firms, many of […]

Read More
10 April 2017

The Institutional Voting Process at AGM’s and the Value of Vote Tracking

Daniel Jones, Shareholder Analytics The Scenario We’ve all seen it; a company in the midst of a contentious voting situation at an AGM with management nervously waiting on the final proxy vote count. Less than 48 hours before proxy voting is due to close, a significant number of votes are lodged with the Share Registry […]

Read More
11 February 2016

IR Managers: Think your firm has no peers? Think again!

I’ve heard it time and time again. “We cannot target investors based on a peer analysis because we… …have no peers …no direct peers” …no local peers” …no peers of the same size” To you that subscribe to this view I would like to challenge your definition of a peer. Whilst in your eyes a […]

Read More
30 November 2015

It’s Enough to Give Your CEO Nightmares

FIRST Advisers, Investor Tracking and Solicitation An unknown shareholder has doubled their shareholding in your company overnight but they can’t be identified because they are protected by privacy legislation in their offshore jurisdiction. Or suddenly one day that unassuming one per cent shareholding held in a prime broker intermediary account disappears and is replaced by […]

Read More
2 December 2014

7 tips for Soliciting Shareholder Vote

In an age when the interactions between listed companies and their shareholders are increasingly automated and carried out electronically, the relatively low tech practice of soliciting votes still has a decisive role to play when companies need to win support from investors. The two strike rule at annual general meetings, increasingly bold activist investors and […]

Read More